Okay, so….keep in mind I had half a bottle of a very fine Argentinian Malbec tonight while watching the proceedings at Saddleback hosted by Ricky. I will paraphrase my impressions with this caveat.
On Abortion (At what point does a human life have rights – or something like that):
Obama: “Well, this is a very difficult issue and of course we want to do everything we can do decrease the number of abortions……..this is a difficult decision….) etc.
McCan: “At conception.”
On a time when they made a decision that went against their party:
Obama: “Well….it was when I worked with John McCain and others on campaign finance reform…I think neither party was happy with this..in fact I had some people whisper to me…’Where are we gonna eat? McDonald’s?’…..” Okay this was funny I have to admit.
McCain” “It was the time when some wanted to move a peace-keeping force into Beirut and I thought there was no way it would end well having a small number of American troops in that region…and it was hard to go against Ronald Reagan for whom I worked and deeply respected and also my party…and I voted against it….and then the Marine barracks was bombed and we lost over 100 brave soles…..”
On evil in the world:
Obma: “Yes there is evil in the world and we must confront it….it’s in all of us..it’s on the streets and it’s in the world….”
McCain: “We must defeat it….I will hunt Usama Bin Laden to the gates of hell and I will get him…..I know how to do it and I will.”
On Supreme Court Justices (which ones would you not have nominated and why):
Obama: Clarence Thomas. Scalia. And Roberts. He said something about how Thomas didn’t have the experience or knowledge necessary to be on the The Supreme Court.
McCain: Ginsburg. Stevens. Souter. Breyer. Because he thinks presidents should choose justices that follow the Consitution and do not legislate from the bench.
On the most gut-wrenching decision they’ve made in their lives:
Obama: The vote against going to war with Iraq.
McCain: The decision to not go home early from the prison in Vietman…first in, first out. That was the code and he stood by it. And…he was glad that when he made that decision he did not know the war would last another three years.
On three people that would pay key roles in advising their administrations:
Obama: Mom, Grandmother, Wife. Verious senators. Veaious points of view where his assumptions would be challenged…..etc.
McCain: General Petraeus, The founder of eBAY and one other guy theyr’e saying is an African-American and a civil rights leader (sorry…the buzz will not allow me to remember his name – I’m sure you can find links later).
On Merit Pay for teachers:
Obama: “Yes, I think merit pay is a good idea and we should work with teachers to be sure they agree with the parameters set down and it should not be decided on one test……”
McCain: “Yes to merit pay and we should work hard to find bad teachers another profession……yes to vouchers, yes to choice, yes to competition….everyone gets the opportunity for an education but what kind of education is that if we send them to a failing school?”
On adoptions and whether or not they would commit to a similar program that Bush has done for AIDS that contains emergency measures:
Obama: “Adoption is good…” okay, I confess I didn’t listen to much else about his answer because seriously…his answers were long and hard to understand.
McCain: “I strongly support adoption…my wife brought home a dying infant from Mother Theresa’s orphanage in Bangladesh which we adopted and she is now 17 and we love her dearly (or something like that)…”
Note: Neither one of them would commit to an emergency program that would address the 148 million orphans in the world.
On faith in their lives:
Obama: “……various phrases about Jesus being his savior, etc.”
McCain: “One time in Vietman…a guy came in and loosened my bonds for a few hours, hushing me so as not to warn the others…and another time on Christmas a guard came by while I had a few minutes outside my cell, drew a cross in the sand with his sandal, and for a moment we stood together, just two christians worshiping the lord…then he scrubbed out the cross and moved on…I will never forget that day or what that guard did, and Christianity is in every day of my life….”
On “What IS rich?”
Obama: Basically, he said $250,000.00.
McCain: He said he wants everyone to be rich and promised not to raise taxes on anyone and he does NOT believe in redistribution of wealth and then threw out an arbitrary number of five million, which I’m sure the left will have a field day with. But I did like the idea of no new taxes for anyone.
On what it would take for you decide to take American troops to war:
Um….neither one of them answered this. Except both of them said if American blood was spilled that would be a reason…and McCain talked about the situation in Georgia with experience and context (I know…I’m in the bag for McCain but what can I say? I’m “in the bag” for fighter pilots…hell, I married one).
Conclusions:
While I think Obama was smooth, if anyone bothered to look under the hood on his answers I think they would be as frustrated as I am in that I STILL don’t know what his experience really is or what he would do as president…except that he would go for a hard left and seek to redistribute as much of our nation’s wealth as possible to those who for some reason think they are entitled to the hard earnings of others.
McCain has a very strong moral compass. He is a war-hardened, decisive veteran who has made hard choices for the good of the country – not himself. He has gone against his party on many issues, and is not afraid to speak his mind and tell you who he is.